Book: Indonesian Scholar Proves The Falsity of The Ba 'Alawi Lineage Connecting to the Prophet Muhammad

Book: An Indonesian Scholar Proves The Falsity of The Ba 'Alawi Lineage Connecting to the Prophet Muhammad Author: KH. Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani

Book: An Indonesian Scholar Proves The Falsity of The Ba 'Alawi Lineage Connecting to the Prophet Muhammad
Book title:  An Indonesian Scholar Proves The Falsity of The Ba 'Alawi Lineage Connecting to the Prophet Muhammad 
Author: KH. Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani, Indonesia
Title of Original / Indonesian version: Ulama Nusantara Menggugat Nasab Palsu: Jawaban KH. Imaduddin Utsman al-Bantani terhadap Buku Hanif Alatas dkk
Penulis: KH. Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani, pengasuh pesantren Nahdlatul Ulum, Banten
Cetakan pertama: November 2024
Penerbit:  Lakeisha 2024
15,6 cm X 23 cm, 691 Halaman
ISBN : 978-623-119-469-5 
Bidang studi: Sejarah Baalawi, sejarah Nabi, ilmu nasab, sejarah Islam, genealogi, garis keturunan, filologi/manuskrip, Tes DNA 
Publisher of English version: Al-Khoirot Research and Publication 
Fields of study: Ba'alawi history, history of the Prophet, science of lineage, Islamic history, genealogy, bloodline / lineage, philology/manuscripts, DNA testing 

Table of Contents

  1. DOWNLOAD THE BOOK (PDF)
  2. FOREWORD
  3. PART ONE: NUSANTARA SCHOLARS CHALLENGE FABRICATED LINEAGE (KH Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani’s Response to the Book by Hanif Alatas et al.)
    1. Responding to the Prologue of Hanif Alatas’ Book
    2. Responding To The Foreword By Ahmad Sa’dullah Abdul Alim Of Sidogiri Pasuruan 
    3. Responding To The Foreword By Muhammad Najih Sarang
    4. Responding To The Foreword By Abdullah Mukhtar Sukabumi
    5. Responding To The Foreword By K.H. Syukron Makmun
    6. Responding To The Foreword By Kurtubi Lebak
    7. Responding To The Foreword By Abdul Shomad Riau
  4. Chapter I: Responding to the Claims of the Ba Alawi Lineage According to Lineage Science, Jurisprudence, and History
  5. Section 1 the Benchmark for the Validity of Lineage
    1. Establishment of Lineage According to Lineage Scholars 
    2. The First Method of Lineage Validation (Ithbat Nasab): Al-Shuhrah wa al-Istifadah 
    3. The Meaning of Shuhrah Wa al-Istifadah Being Min Azhar al-Bayyinat
    4. Istifadah or Tasamu’ Must Occur in the Ancestral Village, Not in the Land of Migration 
    5. The Second Method of Lineage Validation (Itsbat Nasab): Lineage Books
    6. Arguments Regarding Contemporary Books
    7. Discovering a Manuscript
    8. The Third Method of Lineage Validation (Itsbat Nasab): Bayyinah Syar’iyyah / Syahadah 
    9. The Fourth Method of Lineage Validation (Itsbat Nasab): Al-I’tiraf and Iqrar by a Tribe
    10. The Fifth Method of Lineage Validation (Itsbat Nasab): I’tiraf and Iqrar by a Father 
    11. The Sixth Method of Lineage Validation (Itsbet Nasab): Al-Qur’ah
    12. The Seventh Method of Lineage Validation (Itsbat Nasab): Qiyafah 
    13. Regarding Arab DNA 
    14. The Legal Ruling (Sharia Law) on DNA Testing to Verify Descent from Prophet Muhammad  
  6.  Section 2: The Books Indicating The Ba‘Alwi Lineage Is Dead-Ended In The 9th Century
    1. Lineage Books from the 3rd to the 13th Century Hijri
    2. Books Obtained by the Ba‘alawi
  7. Section 3: Answering The Claims Of Recognition And Testimony By The Scholars Regarding The Validity Of The Sadah Ba'alwi Lineage 
    1. The Manuscript of Hasan al-'Allal (460 AH)
    2. The Chain of Transmission (Sanad) of Abul Qasim al-Naffath (490 AH)
    3. The Manuscript of Hasan bin Rasyid (638 AH)
    4. The Manuscript of Umar bin Sa'ad al-Din al-Dzifari
    5. The Manuscript of the Authorization (Ijazah) of Kitab Sunan Turmudzi from the Year 589 AH
    6. Kitab Tuhfat al-Murid Wa Uns al-Mustafid
    7. The Manuscript of Abul Qasim al-Naffath
    8. The Chain of Transmission (Sanad) of Muhammad Aqilah and the Assegaf Manuscript 
    9. The Manuscript of the Book Musnad Ubaidillah al-Tamimi al-Iraqi
    10. The Manuscript of the Chain of Transmission of Abdul Haq al-Isbili Ibn al-Kharrat
    11. The Manuscript of the Chain of Transmission of Ali al-Syanini
    12. The Manuscript of Al-Thurfat al-Gharibat
    13. Al-Suluk Fi Thabaqat al-Ulama wa al-Muluk by Bahauddin al-Janadi (d. 732 AH)
    14. Kitab Al-Athaya al-Saniyah by Al-Malik al-Abbas (d. 778 AH)
    15. Kitab Al-'Iqd al-Fakhir by Al-Khazraji (d. 812 AH)
    16. Kitab Al-'Iqd al-Tsamin by Muhammad bin Ahmad al-Fasi al-Makki (d. 832 AH)
    17. Kitab Al-Nafhah al-Anbariyah by Muhammad Kadzim (d. 880 AH)
    18. The Names of the Jadid Family Mentioned in Al-Suluk Appropriated by the Abdurrahman Assegaf Family
    19. The Tragedy of Abu Marwan
    20. Hasan Bin Muhammad Bin Ali Ba'alwi
    21. Ali Bin Ba'alwi, the One Who Sent Greetings to the Messenger of Allah 
    22. Syarif Abul Jadid is Not a Descendant of Ahmad bin Isa
    23. Tuhfat al-Zaman by Husain al-Ahdal (d. 855 AH)
    24. Thabaqat al-Khawash by Al-Syarji al-Zabidi (d. 893 AH)
  8. Section 4: The Recognition Of The Great Scholars Of The Archipelago Toward The Ba'alwi Status As Descendants Of The Prophet
    1. Sheikh Nawawi al-Bantani (d. 1316 AH)
    2. Sheikh Hasyim Asy'ari (d. 1366 AH) 
    3. Abdullah and Ubaidillah
  9.  Section 5: The Validation of Lineage Through the Method of Istifadah
    1. The Meaning of Shuhrah Wa al-Istifadah as "Min Adhar al-Bayyinat"
    2. Istifadah or Tasamu' Must Occur in the Local Place of Origin, Not in the Land of Migration 
  10. Section 6: The Early Historical Vestiges of the Ba'alwi Sadah in Hadramaut 
    1. The Tomb of Ahmad bin 'Isa
    2. Muhammad Shahib Mirbat 
    3. The Tomb of Muhammad Sahib Mirbat 
  11. Chapter II: Answering The Accusations Of Hanif Et Al. Against The Author's Thesis (Kh Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani) 
  12. Methods of Lineage Verification (Ithbat Nasab)
    1. The Method of Syuhrah wal-Istifadhah (Renown and Diffusiveness) 
    2. The Method of Genealogy Books
    3. The Method of Syahadah / Al-Bayyinah al-Syar'iyyah (Legal Testimony)
    4. The Method of Ikrar (Acknowledgment)
    5. The Method of I'tiraf (Recognition)
    6. The Method of Qiyafah (Physiognomy)
    7. The Method of DNA Testing
    8. The Method of Qur'ah (Drawing Lots)
  13. Classification of Lineage According to Genealogy Experts
  14. The Rules of Lineage Scholars in Nullifying the Ba‘alwi Lineage (Rules 1 to 14) 
    1. Rule 1: Vested Interest 
    2. Rule 2: Early Genealogy Books
    3. Rule 3: Illogical Speech or Solely Upon Collective Folk Memory
    4. Rule 4: Secondary Reference (Marji') Differs From a Primary Source
    5. Rule 5: Specific Genealogy Books
    6. Rule 6: Fabricated and Forged Information 
    7. Rule 7: Never Treat Texts as Sacred
    8. Rule 8: No One above the Scrutiny
    9. Rule 9: Many Sources are Useless if it comes from one source
    10. Rule 10: Once the fabricator is identified, the validity of the deduction (istidlal) collapses
    11. Rule 11: Genealogy Expert  Be Prioritized
    12. Rule 12: Authoritative Primary Sources and References
    13. Rule 13: Absolute Textual Certainty (Qath'iy Al-Dalalah)
    14. Rule 14: Mentioning "Sayyid" Does not Mean verification of lineage
  15. Answering the Accusations of Hanif Alatas 
    1. Answering the Framing by Hanif et al. That the Author Opposes, Ignores, and Belittles the Recognition of Mutabar (Authoritative) Scholars Concerning the Ba'alwi Lineage  Scholars Who Recognize Versus Those Who Reject
    2. Recognition from Scholars Answered with Assumptions
    3. Imam Ibn Hajar Al-Haytami 
    4. If the Ba‘alwi Lineage Were Brought to a Bahtsul Masail (Legal Forum) by NU 
    5. Logical Fallacies
    6. Unmentioned Means Non-Existent
    7. The Book Al-Syajarah Al-Mubarakah is a Mukhtasar (Abridged) Book
    8. The Nominal Sentence (Jumlah Ismiyyah) in Al-Syajarah Al-Mubarakah is Hashr (Restrictive)
    9. Efforts by Hanif et al. to Cast Doubt on the Book Al-Syajarah Al-Mubarakah
    10. Doubting Al-Syajarah Al-Mubarakah Because of Imam Mahdi
    11. Inaccuracy of the Restrictive (Hashr) Claim According to Hanif et al.
    12. The Answer of Mahdi al-Raja'i Used as Proof by Hanif et al.  
    13. Responding to the Defamatory Framing of the Scholars
    14. Slandering Ali bin Abu Bakar al-Sakran
    15. Abdurrahman al-Khatib and the Book Al-Jawhar al-Syafaf
    16. Slandering the Ba'alwi in General
    17. The Ba'alwi and Bani Ahdal
    18. Slander Against Alwi bin Tahir al-Haddad
    19. Slander Against Imam Murtada al-Zabidi (d. 1204 AH)
    20. Slander Against Yusuf Jamalullail
    21. Scientific Betrayal: The Difficulty of Accepting References that Validate the Ba'alwi Lineage
    22. Using Theories but Ignoring the Ba'alwi
    23. Demanding Contemporary Books While Not Utilizing Contemporary Sources Himself
    24. Frequently Rejecting the Validity of Books Validating the Ba'alwi while Uncritically Accepting Books Rejecting the Ba'alwi
    25. Deception in Citations
    26. Twisting Proofs from the Al-Qur'an and Sunnah Regarding the Title "Habib"
    27. There is No Sahih Hadith Regarding the Obligation to Love the Descendants of the Prophet 
    28. Haphazard Conclusion Making
    29. Ba'alwi are Descendants of Qahtan 
    30. The Grandfather of the Ba'alwi Was a Direct First Cousin to the Bani Ahdal
    31. Ahmad bin Isa Never Migrated to Hadramaut
    32. Hanif Manipulated Data from the Book Al-Ghaybah by Al-Tusi Regarding Ahmad bin Isa Never Migrating to Hadramaut
    33. The Grave of Ahmad bin Isa is Fake
    34.  Committing Public Deception: The Ba'alwi Lineage is Severed for 550 Years 
    35. The Mufti of Yemen Nullifies the Ba'alawi Lineage 
    36. International Naqabah Does Not Recognize the Ba'alwi Lineage
    37. Sheikh Al-Turbani Nullifies the Ba'alwi Lineage
    38. The Conclusion that the Ba'alwi Lineage is Nullified is a Thesis
    39. Plagiarizing the Thoughts of Orientalists and Non-Aswaja Figures
    40. Copying Wahhabi Figures in Nullifying the Ba'alwi Lineage
    41. Lacking Competence in the Science of Genealogy
    42. Invalidating Distant Lineage Through DNA Testing
  16. Chapter III: The Harm (Mafasid) Of Ba‘Alwi Claiming to be Descendants of the Prophet
    1. Trapped in Defaming Lineages (Ta‘n fi al-Nasab)
    2. Pitting Kiais, Habaib, and the Ummah Against One Another
    3. Opening the Door to Istihza (Derision) Toward Scholars and Saints
    4. Spreading Racial Hatred Within the Ummah
    5. Weakening the Integrity and Scholarship of NU Scholars 
  17. PART TWO: MEASURING THE AUTHENTICITY OF THE HABIB LINEAGE IN INDONESIA
    1. Foreword
    2. Habib Ba Alawi in Indonesia 
    3. Methods For Establishing Lineage (Nasab)
      1. Lookinh Up
      2. Looking Down 
    4. Methods For Confirming Lineage Books (Kitab Nasab)
    5. Method For Confirming Alawi Bin Ubaidillah  
    6. Evidence That Prophet Muhammad S.A.W. Had A Child Named Fatimah
    7. Evidence That Siti Fatimah R.A. Had A Child Named Husain 
    8. Evidence Stating That Husain R.A. Had A Child Named Ali Zainal Abidin And So Forth Down To Ali Al-Uraidhi
    9. Evidence That Ali Al-Uraidhi Had A Child Named Muhammad An-Naqib   
    10. Evidence That Muhammad An-Naqib Had A Child Named Isa
    11. Evidence That Isa Bin Muhammad Had A Child Named Ahmad (Al-Muhajir)  
    12. There is No Evidence That Ahmad Al-Muhajir Bin Isa Had A Son Named Ubaidillah
      1. Fifth Century Hijri Book
      2. Sixth Century Hijri Book
      3. Seventh Century Hijri Book 
      4. Eighth Century Hijri Book
      5. Ninth Century Hijri Book 
    13. The Appearance of the Name Abdullah at the End of the 9th Century Hijri
    14. In the 10th Century, the Name Abdullah and His Descendants Began to Mature, Although He Was Not Yet Referred to as Ubaidillah
    15. Is the Abdullah of the 9th Century AH the Same as the Abdullah of the 10th Century AH? 
    16. Abdullah Officially Becomes Ubaidillah in the 14th Century AH
    17. Conclusion of the Scientific Research
    18. Scientific Research is Not the Ultimate Truth  
  18. PART THREE: THE SEVERED LINEAGE OF THE HABIBS TO THE PROPHET MUHAMMAD SAW 
  19. Preface
  20. Chapter I: Habib Ba Alawi in Indonesia 
  21. Chapter II: Methods of Determining Lineage
    1. The Method Of Confirming Genealogical Books
    2. The "Looking Up" Method (Mushajjar)
    3. The "Looking Down" Method (Mubashath)
    4. References 
  22. Chapter III: Method for Confirming Alawi ibn Ubaidillah 
    1. Evidence That Prophet Muhammad Pbuh Had A Child Named Fatimah R.A. 
    2. Evidence That Sayyidah Fatimah R.A. Had A Child Named Husain R.A.
    3. Evidence Stating That Husain R.A. Had A Child Named Ali Zainal Abidin And So Forth Down To Ali Al-Uraidhi
    4. Evidence That Ali Al-Uraidhi (219 Ah) Had A Child Named Muhammad An-Naqib (250 Ah)
    5. Evidence That Muhammad Al-Naqib (250 Ah) Had A Son Named Isa (300 Ah)
    6. Evidence That Isa Bin Muhammad (300 Ah) Had A Son Named Ahmad (345 Ah)
    7. Evidence That Ahmad Al-Abah (345 Ah) Al-Naffat Bin Isa Had A Son Named Ubaidillah (383 Ah)
    8. Fifth-Century Hijri Books
    9. Sixth-Century Hijri Books
    10. Seventh-Century Hijri Books
    11. Eighth-Century Hijri Books
    12. The Appearance of the Name Abdullah in Historical Books
    13. Ninth-Century Hijri Books
    14. The Appearance of the Name Abdullah at the End of the 9th Century AH
    15. Habib Ali Al-Sakran: The First Person To Mention The Name Ubaidillah As The Son of Ahmad
    16. The Argument of Habib Ali al-Sakran (d. 895 AH) That Ubaid Is Another Name for Abdullah 
    17. Abdullah Is Not Ubaidillah In The Book Al-Suluk
    18. The Tenth Century: The Names Ubaidillah and His Descendants Begin to Mature, Although Not Yet Referred to as Ubaidillah 
    19. Abdullah Officially Becomes Ubaidillah In The 14th Century AH
    20. The Ba Alawi Lineage Lacks Syuhroh (fame) and istifadoh (widespread transmission)
    21. Conclusion
    22. Referenses 
  23. Chapter IV: Responses to Refutations 
    1. Responses to The Rabitah Alawiyah Letter
    2. Response To The Refutation By Habib Rizieq Syihab 
    3. Response To The Book By Hanif Alatas
    4. Response To Hanif Alatas (Part 2): Rangginang From Banten For Hanif Alatas
    5. Ubaidillah And Abdullah Are Not The Same Person Based On The Book Al-Suluk
    6. Responding To Habib Ali Zainal Abidin, Chairman Of Naqobatul Asyrof Rabitah Alawiyah, And Sheikh Mahdi Arroja'i
    7. Answering Sheikh Mahdi Arroja'i
    8. Answering The Claim That The Habib Lineage Has Been Mentioned By Great Scholars
    9. Habib Ali Al-Sakran
    10. Sheikh Yusuf An-Nabhani
    11. Ibnu Hajar Al-Haitami
    12. Murtadha Az-Zabidi
    13. Sheikh Mahdi Arroja'i
    14. Responding To Muhammad Ludfi Rochman (1): Regarding The Discontinuity Of The Habib Lineage
    15. Muhammad Ludfi Rahman (2): Defends The Habib Lineage With A Forged Book
    16. Review Of The Scholarly Dialogue With Habib Hamid Alkadri Concerning The Habib Lineage
    17. Responding To The Statement: "Not Being Mentioned Does Not Mean Non-Existence"
    18. Response To The Statement: Denying Ubaidillah As Ahmad's Son Constitutes An Accusation Of Adultery (Qadzaf)
    19. Response To The Claim: Researching The Habib Lineage Is Equivalent To Hating The Descendants Of Prophet Muhammad Saw.
    20. Response To The Claim: Sheikh Nawawi Al-Bantani, Sheikh Hasyim Asy'ari, Etc., Have Validated (Itsbat) The Ba Alawi Lineage
    21. Response To The Book By Dr. Ja'far Assegaf, Ma. Titled Connectivity Of Rijal Al-Hadith With History In Tracing Lineage
  24. Chapter V: Scholars' Reviews of the Author's Research 
    1. Questioning the Genealogy of Habibs in Indonesia to the Messenger of Allah: Scientific Evidence of Kyai Imaduddin Utsman By Dr. Syafiq Hasyim 
    2. The Ba Alawi Lineage Polemic By Kholili Kholil 
    3. When the Habib Lineage Becomes a Polemic (Measuring the Historical Analysis of the Ba Alawi by Kyai Imaduddin Utsman al-Bantani) By KH. Khotimi Bahri
    4. KH. Imaduddin Utsman: Between Scientific Honesty and Historical Tyranny By KH. Khotimi Bahri
    5. Turmoil Regarding Lineage: Here is What Prof. Dr. Quraish Shihab Says
    6. The Collapse of Habaib Legitimacy By: Ickur
    7. Scientific Study of the Ba'alawi Lineage Does Not Oppose the Lineage of Walisongo Ancestors By: R.Tb.M. Nurfadhil Satya Tirtayasa 
  25. PART FOUR: THE SCIENTIFIC SCANDAL OF THE BA 'ALAWI (OR BANĪ 'ALAWĪ) LINEAGE AND GENEALOGY
  26. Preface
  27. Introduction
    1. Ahmad bin ‘Isa Never Migrated to Hadramaut 
    2. The Tomb of Ahmad bin Isa
    3. Ahmad Bin Isa Was Not Titled "Al-Muhajir"
    4. Ahmad Bin Isa Did Not Have Children Named Abdullah or Ubaidillah 
    5. The Lineage of Syarif Abil Jadid from the Clan of Alu Abi Alwi
    6. The Family of Abdurrahman Al-Saqqaf Claiming to be Alu Abi Alawi 
    7. Alawi Becomes the Brother of Syarif Abul Jadid 
    8. Jadid Has No Connection to the Ba'alwi Family
    9. The Book Tabaqat al-Khawash Witnesses the Efforts to Synchronize the Ba'alwi Lineage 
    10. The Account of Muhammad bin Sulaiman's Migration Becomes Out of Sync
    11. Ubaidillah and Fictitious Names from the Ba’alwi Family 
    12. Glorification of the Ba’alwi Ancestors
    13. Interpolation and the Scientific Morals of the Ba’alwi 
    14. Conclusion 
    15. Bibliography  
  28. PART FIVE: METHODS OF DETERMINING LINEAGE ACCORDING TO THE BOOK RASA’IL FI ‘ILM AL-ANSAB: A CASE STUDY OF THE BA‘ALWI LINEAGE
  29. Introduction
  30. CHAPTER I: THE TEXT OF THE BOOK RASA'IL FI 'ILM AL-ANSAB
    1. The Verification of Lineage According to Genealogists
    2. The First Method: The widespread notoriety (istifadah) of a lineage and its fame (syuhrah) in one's home territory
    3. The Second Method: The books of substitute genealogists (abdal)
    4. The Third Method: The establishment of legal proof (al-bayyinah al-syar'iyyah)
    5. The Fourth Method: That the tribe itself acknowledges and admits, for an individual or a group, the truth and validity of their lineage
    6. The Fifth Method: That a sane man acknowledges and admits that a certain individual is his son
    7. The Sixth Method: The drawing of lots (al-qur'ah)
    8. The Seventh Method: Human physiognomy (qiyafat al-bashar)
    9. Methods Validated by Biologists 
  31. CHAPTER II: Commentary (Sharah) On The Methods Of Verifying Lineage In The Book Rasa'il: A Case Study Of The Ba'alwi Lineage
    1. The First Method of Lineage Verification: Al-Syuhrah Wa Al-Istifadah
    2. The True Meaning of Widespread Notoriety as "Min Azhar al-Bayyinat"
    3. The Second Method of Lineage Verification: Genealogical Books
    4. The Rule of Contemporary Texts
    5. The Discovery of Manuscripts
    6. The Third Method: Bayyinah Syar'iyyah / Syahadah (Legal Testimony)
    7. The Fourth Method: Al-I'tiraf and Iqrar (Acknowledgment and Affirmation) by a Tribe
    8. The Fifth Method: I'tiraf and Iqrar by a Father
    9. The Sixth Method: Al-Qur'ah (Drawing Lots)
    10. The Seventh Method: Qiyafah (Physiognomy)
    11. Methods Established by Biologists
    12. Regarding Arab DNA
    13. The Ruling (Hukum) on DNA Testing to Verify the Descent from the Prophet Muhammad PBUH 
  32. PART SIX: LIST OF LINEAGE BOOK LITERATURE OF THE 3RD–13TH CENTURIES AH: EVIDENCE OF THE NULLIFICATION OF THE BA’ALWI LINEAGE
    1. Foreword 
    2. The Book Nasabu Quraish (3rd Century) 
    3. The Book Sirri Silsilat al-Alawiyyah (4th Century)
    4. The Book Tahdzib al-Ansab (5th Century) 
    5. The Book Al-Majdi (5th Century)
    6. The Book Al-Muntaqilat al-Thalibiyyah (5th Century)
    7. The Book Abna' al-Imam Fi Mishra Wa al-Syam (5th Century)
    8. The Book Al-Syajarah al-Mubarakah (7th Century) 
    9. The Book Al-Fakhri Fi Ansab al-Thalibiyyin (7th Century)
    10. The Book Al-Ashili Fi Ansab al-Thalibiyyin (8th Century)
    11. The Book Al-Thabat al-Musan (8th Century)
    12. The Book Umdat al-Talib al-Shugra (9th Century)
    13. The Book Umdat al-Talib Fi Ansab Al-Abi Thalib (9th Century)
    14. The Book Al-Nafhah al-Anbariyyah (9th Century) 
    15. The Book Shihah al-Akhbar (9th Century)
    16. The Book Bahr al-Ansab or Al-Musyajjar al-Kasyaf (10th Century)
    17. The Book Tuhfat al-Thalib (10th Century)
    18. The Book Tuhfat al-Azhar (11th Century)
    19. The Book Al-Raudh al-Jaliy (13th Century) 
    20. Conclusion   
  33. PART SEVEN: SPURIOUS MANUSCRIPTS OF THE BA'ALAWI ACCORDING TO RUMAIL ABBAS'S VERSION
  34. Foreword
  35. Chapter I: Introduction
  36. CHAPTER II: RUMAIL ABBAS'S MANUSCRIPTS
    1. (1) The Manuscript of Hasan al-Allal (460 AH) 
    2. (2) The Manuscript of Umar bin Sa'ad al-Din al-Dzifari 
    3. (3) The Manuscript of the Sunan Tirmidhi Kitab License (Ijazah) Dated 589 AH 
    4. (4) The Book Tuhfat al-Murid Wa Uns al-Mustafid
    5. (5) The Manuscript of Abul Qasim al-Naffath 
    6. (6) The Chain of Narration of Muhammad Aqilah and the Assegaf Manuscript
    7. (7) The Manuscript of the Book Musnad Ubaidillah al-Tamimi al-Iraqi 
    8. (8) The Manuscript of the Chain of Narration of Abdul Haq al-Isybili Ibnu al-Kharrath
    9. (9) The Manuscript of Ali al-Syanini's Chain of Narration
    10. (10) The Manuscript of Al-Thurfat al-Gharibat   
  37. CHAPTER III: CONCLUSION
  38. Similar Books 
    1. Assessing the Authenticity of the Habib Lineage in Indonesia 
    2. The Discontinuity of the Habib Lineage to the Prophet Muhammad PBUH 
    3. Methods of Verifying Lineage According to the Book Rasa'il Fi 'Ilm Al-Ansab  
    4. Exposing the Scholarly Scandal of Ba’alawi History and Genealogy: The Finalization of the Ba‘alwi Genealogical Severance from the Prophet Muhammad PBUH
    5. Indonesian Scholar Proves The Falsity of The Ba 'Alawi Lineage Connecting to the Prophet Muhammad  
  39.  Islamic English Books

Foreword

Rabithah Alawiyyah, as the organization that records the descendants of the Ba‘alawi in Indonesia, should be held responsible to its members regarding the severed Ba‘alawi lineage. Instead, the organization chose to "assign" a team called the "Team to Guard Ummah Unity" (Tim Pengawal Persatuan Umat) to produce a book titled "Keabsahan Nasab Ba‘alwi Membongkar Penyimpangan Pembatalnya" (The Validity of the Ba'alawi Lineage: Exposing the Deviations of its Nullifiers), without making any mention of Rabithah Alawiyyah. This book serves as a response to the author's thesis that the Ba‘alawi clan are not descendants of the Prophet Muhammad SAW.

The author's thesis is presented in several books and articles written in both Arabic and Indonesian. The author’s books in Indonesian concerning the nullification of the Ba‘alawi lineage are:

  1. Menakar Kesahihan Nasab Habib di Indonesia: Sebuah Penelitian Ilmiyah (Measuring the Authenticity of the Habib Lineage in Indonesia: A Scientific Research) – October 2022
  2. Terputusnya Nasab Habib Kepada Nabi Muhammad SAW (Penyempurnaan dari Buku Menakar Kesahihan Nasab Habib di Indonesia) (The Broken Lineage of the Habibs to the Prophet Muhammad SAW [A Refinement of the Book 'Measuring the Authenticity of the Habib Lineage in Indonesia']) – May 2023
  3. Membongkar Skandal Ilmiyah Genealogi dan Sejarah Ba‘alwi (Finalisasi Keterputusan Genealogi Ba‘alwi Kepada Nabi Muhammad SAW) (Exposing the Scientific Scandal of Ba'alawi Genealogy and History [The Finalization of the Severed Ba‘alawi Genealogy to the Prophet Muhammad SAW]) – February 2024
  4. Kronik Perjalanan Ilmiyah K.H. Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani Dalam Mengungkap Nasab Palsu Ba‘alwi (The Chronicle of the Scientific Journey of K.H. Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani in Uncovering the Fabricated Ba‘alawi Lineage) – May 2024
  5. Ilmu Nasab Istilah dan Metodologi (The Science of Lineage: Terminology and Methodology) – 2023
  6. Metode Menetapkan Nasab Menurut Kitab Rasa‘il Fi ’Ilm Al-Ansab Studi Case Nasab Ba‘alwi (Methods of Determining Lineage According to the Book 'Rasa'il Fi 'Ilm Al-Ansab': A Case Study of the Ba‘alawi Lineage) – September 2024
  7. Literatur Kitab-Kitab Nasab Abad Ke-3-13 Hijriyah Bukti Keterputusan Nasab Ba‘alwi (Lineage Book Literature of the 3rd–13th Centuries AH: Evidence of the Severed Ba‘alawi Lineage) – September 2024
  8. Manuskrip-Manuskrip Palsu Ba‘alwi Versi Rumail Abbas (Fabricated Ba‘alawi Manuscripts: Rumail Abbas' Version) – September 2024

Meanwhile, the author's books presenting the thesis on the nullification of the Ba‘alawi lineage written in Arabic are:

  1. Al-Mawahib al-Laduniyyah fi Inqita' Nasab Ba‘alwi bin Ubaidillah – Dzulqa'dah 1444 AH
  2. I'anat al-Akhyar fi Jawab al-Syekh Muhammad Abdillah Mukhtar – Muharram 1445 AH
  3. Kashf al-Fadihah al-Ilmiyyah li nasab wa tarikh Ba'alwi (An Arabic translation of the book Membongkar Skandal Ilmiyah Genealogi dan Sejarah Ba‘alwi) – February 2024
  4. Al-Ma'arif al-Rabbaniyyah fi Hifdz Nuthfat al-Nabawiyyah – Rabi‘ al-Awwal 1446 AH

In 2023, the publisher "Oncor Semesta Ilmu" in Jogjakarta published an anthology of the author's books and texts titled: Habaib Keturunan Nabi Benarkah (Politik Identitas-Pengaruh-Keagungan) (Are the Habibs Descendants of the Prophet?: Identity Politics, Influence, and Nobility).

Several books have been written to answer the author's thesis, in both Indonesian and Arabic. Among these books are:

  1. Al-Radd fi Man Yunkiru Ansab Sadat Ba'alwi, 5 pages, written by Amjad bin Salim bin Abdullah Abu Futaim bin Syekh Abubakar bin Salim from Tarim – Ramadan 1444 AH
  2. Konektifitas Rijalul Hadits Dengan Sejarah Dalam Menelusuri Nasab (The Connectivity of Rijal al-Hadith with History in Tracing Lineage), 77 pages, written by Dr. Ja'far Assegaf – March 2023
  3. Risalah Ilmiyah Jawaban Atas Syubhat Imaduddin Utsman Seputar Keabsyahan Bani Alawi (A Scientific Treatise: Responses to the Doubts of Imaduddin Utsman Concerning the Legitimacy of the Bani Alawi), 45 pages, written by Hanif Alatas, Jakarta – Ramadan 1444 AH
  4. Bingkisan Lebaran Untuk Imaduddin Utsman (An Eid Gift for Imaduddin Utsman), 20 pages, written by Hanif Alatas, Jakarta – Shawwal 1445 AH
  5. Al-Husam al-Maslul Fi ‘Unuqi Man Abthala Silsilat Dzurriyyat Al-rasul Abi Fatimah al-Batul, by K.H. Muhammad Abdullah Mukhtar, Sukabumi
  6. Menakar Kesahihan Pembatalan Ba‘alwi (Measuring the Accuracy of the Ba'alawi Nullification), 53 pages, written by Rumail Abbas (Stakof) – December 2023
  7. Ihya al-Mawta, by K.H. Qurtubi, Lebak – Muharram 1446 AH
  8. Keabsahan Nasab Ba‘alwi Membongkar Penyimpangan Pembatalnya, 521 pages, written by the Team to Guard Ummah Unity: Hanif Alatas et al. (Rabithah Alawiyyah).

This final book appears to be the ultimate stronghold of the Ba‘alawi clan in countering the nullification of their lineage. The book now in the hands of the reader will address the contents of that publication. Many propositions in this volume are intentionally reiterated by the author, response by response, to counter identical propositions repeated in the book by Hanif et al. Happy reading.

Imaduddin Utsman Al-Bantani  

DOWNLOAD THE BOOKS

  1. The original & Indonesian version (pdf): 
    1. Ulama Nusantara Menggugat Nasab Palsu (part 3 and final)
    2. Menakar kesahihan Nasab Habib Di Indonesia (part 1)
    3. Terputusnya Nasab Habib Kepada Nabi Muhammad Saw  (part 2)
  2. The English version: (online version, the pdf version coming soon)  
    1. Measuring the Authenticity of Habib Lineage in Indonesia
    2. Discontinuity of the Habib Ba Alawi Lineage to the Prophet Muhammad 
    3. An Indonesian Scholar Proves The Falsity of The Ba 'Alawi Lineage Connecting to the Prophet Muhammad 
  3. The Arabic version (pdf)
    1. Minhaj an-Nassabin | منهاج النسابين 
Tags: Buku, English, Sejarah
LihatTutupKomentar